Theatre 2024: Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812

We originally had tickets to see the musical Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 back in February 2021 before COVID canceled all live theatre.  In January 2024, we were happy to finally be able to watch this demanding show that is based on part of Leo Tolstoy’s epic 1225-pages literary tome War and Peace.  That opus spans from 1805-1820 and weaves fictional interactions between five noble families within the timeframe of the Napoleonic wars.  It also includes lengthy discussions on history and philosophy.  The musical over covers a very small section (less than 100 pages) of the second of 4 books and 2 epilogues within the novel.

As its unwieldy title implies, the musical concentrates on the plight of Countess Natasha Rostova, an impressionable young romantic pining for her fiancé Andrey who is away at war.  Natasha is further disillusioned by Andrey’s father and sister who don’t approve of her.  To distract herself, Natasha travels to Moscow to visit her godmother Marya with her cousin and best friend Sonya accompanying her.  While attending the opera, Natasha meets and is seduced by the lothario Anatole who convinces her to break her engagement to Andrey and “elope” with him instead, despite his already being secretly married. Anatole is the brother of Helene, who is married to the titular Pierre, a wealthy, socially awkward misfit who struggles with philosophical questions that are a reflection Tolstoy’s own beliefs.  Natasha is saved from total ruin when Sonya discovers and foils the elopement plan.  But Natasha has destroyed her chances with Andrey and unsuccessfully attempts suicide in despair. Pierre comforts Natasha and gives her hope for the future, then witnesses the passing of the Great Comet of 1812 (the other part of the musical’s title and a historic phenomenon that was visible by the naked eye for 260 days).

The first song of the show, titled “Prologue”, acknowledges and makes fun of the complicated source material as well as the large cast of characters with lengthy Russian names.  Singing a cumulative song, in the same vein as “Twelve Days of Christmas”, one by one the characters appear on stage to introduce themselves and then each refrain adds the name and main trait of that character to the top of the verse before reviewing all the previous names mentioned.  “.. Anatole is hot .. Marya is old-school .. Sonya is good .. Natasha is young.. and Andrey isn’t here”.  There is a visual family tree included in the program which is actually referred to in the song with the lyrics “If you want to keep up with the plot .. complicated Russian novel .. Everyone’s got nine different names .. So look it up in your program”.  While singing this amusing song, the cast members dance around and actually gesture to the programs on the laps of the audience members sitting in the front rows.

The musical is sung-through meaning that there is no spoken dialogue, except for a few comforting lines expressed by Pierre to Natasha for dramatic effect in the penultimate scene.  Some of the libretto is taken word-for-word from the English translation of War and Peace.  As a result, while most of the lyrics represent dialog between two characters, occasionally they also reflect a character’s inner thoughts or emotions.  When Natasha and Sonya first arrive in Moscow,  Marya praises Natasha on her engagement to Andrey and Natasha next sings “I blush happily”.  This is obviously not part of the conversation, but rather her inner thoughts.  Within the same song, Sonya occasionally turns into a narrator.  When Natasha tells Marya “My cheeks are glowing from the cold”, Sonya sings “She said, gazing at Marya with kind, glittering eyes”.  It is almost as if she is reading text from the novel.  There are also instances where a character sings about himself in third-person as Pierre does in his last interaction with Natasha.  Pierre sings about himself “Pierre sniffed as he looked at her, but he didn’t speak …”.  This constant change of perspective within consecutive lyrics of a song is disconcerting and you have to pay attention to discern between dialogue, internal thoughts and descriptive exposition.

In addition to the lyrics, the music is also challenging to listen to, with its use of dissonant chords, harsh sounds and varying musical styles. The score is a mixture of Russian folk, classical, indie rock and operatic music and is described by the composer as an “electropop opera”.  The songs are definitely not “hum-hum-hummable” to quote an ironic and winkingly self-referential line from Stephen Sondheim’s Merrily We Row Along.  Yet they work when heard in the context of watching the play. These tunes that sounded strange and alienating when merely listening to the soundtrack suddenly feel appropriate and engrossing when supported by the actors in costume, the stagecraft and choreography.

While the main orchestra can be seen situated up high, at the back of the stage and the sides of the theatre, they are supported by some of the actors who also play instruments when they are not the central characters of the current scene.  When the actor who portrays Andrey and Andrey’s crotchety father is not playing his minor roles, he wanders around playing a clarinet.  The actor in the role of Dolokhov, a friend of Anatole who flirts with Helene and gets into a duel with Pierre, plays the accordion, guitar, drums and cello when he is not in a scene.  Looking at the program, you see that many of the musicians are also understudies for the main roles.

As with all the shows that we have watched in the past at Crow’s Theatre, the most impressive part of this musical is the breathtaking staging.  Decked out like a Russian opera house bathed in hues of pink and purple and decorated with gilded railings and sparkling chandeliers, the theatre is set up almost “in the round” with stadium seating on 3 sides, forming a “U” shape around the stage.  The first row of seating on each side consists of small tables to give the theatre an intimate “cabaret-like” feel.  The main stage is a small platform in the centre of the floor with posts on each corner that allow it to be rotated.  High above behind the stage and on both sides above the audience are raised “theatre catwalks” where not only the musicians can be found, but also where some of the scenes take place.  Steep stairs on either side of the stage lead up to the catwalks and during the show, the actors repeatedly run up and down the stairs and in a circular motion along the catwalks, occasionally while carrying and playing instruments.  The energy expended by these actors and musicians is incredible and it felt exhausting merely to watch them.  Because the catwalks do not make a full circle, to complete their circuits, the actors would come back down through the audience, often pausing on the steps to sing their songs.  To follow all the action, you have to look up and down, left and right, front and back, at least if you are lucky enough to be seated in the centre section as we were.  If you are positioned under one of the catwalks, you would miss what was happening above you.

There is much audience interaction in the musical, starting right off the bat with that Prologue song that breaks the fourth wall and talks directly to the crowd to instruct us on how to keep the characters straight by reviewing the program.  This continues throughout the show with the characters wandering up and down the aisles and in one case, Anatole even plops himself in a chair between two female audience members, wrapping his arms around them and chatting for a minute.  In the show, this illustrates a strange Russian custom to sit quietly for a few minutes before embarking on a journey. Another time, Anatole makes his grand exit by running out the back of the theatre, offering to kiss the hand of any audience member who extends it.  I was too shy to stick out my hand but regretted it afterwards as I could have been part of the fun.  In other scenes, some of the people sitting in the front rows were pulled onto the stage to join a dance, share a toast or otherwise participate.

I am assuming that those who wanted to take part chose to come early and claim the seats right up front, since we were forewarned that audience participation would happen. The audience advisory email we received was hilarious as we were told to be prepared for fog, strobe lights, dueling with gunshots, poisoning and (..gasp) ... sleigh riding!!.  In fact, the sleigh ride scene where Anatole prepares to run off with Natasha was the most creative bit of staging of the entire show.  Balaga, the crazy Trokia (a sleigh pulled by 3 horses) driver races with Anatole to retrieve Natasha while singing “Who’s that madman flying at a full gallop… knocking people over..”.  To enact this scene, Balaga stands at the top of the back catwalk and holds long reins in his hands which are attached to the poles on the platform stage below.  As he snaps the reins and sings with the clip-clop sounds of hoofs in the background, you can totally imagine the horses racing in front of him.

The choreography was very impressive in using the allocated space in the small theatre and especially the small stage.  In one party scene, what seemed like the entire cast was twirling and dancing at high speeds on that tiny platform all at once and then a few of the men performed the Russian Squat dance.  One false move and someone would have been accidentally kicked off the stage.  I watched a Broadway version of Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 on Youtube and in my opinion, the intimate setting of the Crow’s Theatre version of worked much better than the staging of the huge Imperial Theatre.  In our theatre, the entire audience was relatively close to the action as opposed to on the gigantic, multi-layered Broadway stage where only the few lucky (?) ones with cabaret table seats right on or in front of the stage had that feeling.  The people in the nosebleed sections of the stadium seating would be too far away.  And while it might have been a cool experience to be sitting in a sunken section on the stage, I’m not sure how much of the show you could actually see from there?

The only time that I was disappointed in the Crow’s Theatre staging of Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 was in the representation of the comet in the final song.  In consoling Natasha, Pierre realizes that he loves her, and that realization brings new energy and meaning to his life.  This is symbolized in his sighting of the comet which before this moment portended disaster and the end of the world.  But now he sings “The comet brings no fear.  No, I gaze upon it joyfully.  This comet .. feels my joyfully uplifted soul, my newly melted heart blossoming into a new life”.  With such big words, the sighting of the “Great” comet should be spectacular, and it is so in the Broadway production.  The lights go dark, hundreds of lights glow as stars in the sky, and then a gigantic celestial orb lights up above the stage.  In the Crow’s theatre production, a small row of 20 lights hanging under the catwalk at the back of the stage light up to represent the comet.  They didn't even darken the stage so that we could see them better. This supposedly miraculous and significantly symbolic sighting turned out to be a bit of a letdown in an otherwise brilliantly staged play.  It is interesting that historically, this comet actually was visible in 1811, not 1812.  Perhaps the word eleven contained too many syllables in an already lengthy title for a musical.

I deliberately selected a show where there was a talkback session with the cast following the performance.  We heard about how some of the actors were musicians first in their careers, and how they dealt with learning their complicated roles.  While watching the show, I thought some of the cast looked familiar and I was right.  Marya was played by Louise Pitre who is best known for starring in Mamma Mia which we watched in 2000.  I first saw her even earlier when she played Mrs. Johnson in Blood Brothers back in 1993.  Evan Buliung who played Pierre was in Fun Home back in 2017.  We actually attended several previous shows starring Hailey Gillis who was Natasha in this one.  She was in Ghost Quartet at Crow’s Theatre in 2019 and back in 2017, we saw her in Onegin which is another operatic period piece with themes very similar to this show.  I asked the production manager whether they were influenced by the staging on Broadway, and he informed me that they were not allowed to use any part of that since it was copyrighted.  This was just as well since for me, the staging for this show was vastly superior.